There
have been a lot of social changes in the Western world over the last one hundred years ...
|
Votes For Women Started The Changes |
..... especially from the point of view of women.
Some such as
the move towards equality under the law, employment opportunities, and
job promotions, are in the main welcome changes, especially for
University educated women who have professional careers (women at the bottom end of the education scale, have possibly not enjoyed so much of these changes). In fact the women's rights and votes for women campaign was strongly linked with the Marie Stopes birth control clinics and movement from the very start of this process.
So one
of the key areas of this social change has been women's control of their bodies
reproductive patterns, which has allowed them to determine whether or when to
have a child. Now in the 1980's and earlier, it was
rare for a university educated woman to have a child out of wedlock, even
if that was not necessarily the case for all women with working class backgrounds. Even as late as
1996, only one in 25 women in their 30's with a university education had
had their first child out of wedlock.
However
a recent study by the John Hopkins University in the USA, has found
that now nearly one in four university educated women had their first
child before marriage ..... a change that can't really be for the better,
but perhaps reflects the times we live in. Money worries, unstable relationships, and the
attainment of other markers, such as career progressions or home
ownership, apparently mean that starting a family later has impacted on
whether the women are prepared to wait for marriage, before they start
that first child.
Now
this control over their reproductive patterns has been a distinguishing
feature of Western culture over other perhaps less enlightened areas, but as
discussed in earlier posts, the rest of the world outside of sub-Saharan Africa have also shown a
reproductive rate drop in the last 30 years, as women's education has spread.
However as the rise of the Taliban has shown, that is a fragile
advancement in many cultures.
|
The US Is Split Over Abortion (As Well As Race) ...
|
But now there are worrying signs that the
US is moving in a retrograde direction on women's right to control their
bodies, with some states such as Texas (
Idaho, Oklahoma and South Carolina have similar laws held up in legal challenges), eliminating the
right to abortion after 6 weeks of
pregnancy,
(replacing the between 22 and 24 weeks federal laws), and even then, they have
virtually removed the ability to actually get the abortion, if the woman
is even aware of being pregnant by the 6 weeks.
This is because the women's health and
family planning centres where abortions are often performed, are often under constant
picket by religious
'right to life' campaigners, who also now have the right in Texas to sue anyone who
"aids and abets" an '
illegal' abortion, which puts the clinics under the constant threat of legal action. The threat is so great that the Federal government has had to declare that they will
protect abortion clinics from physical attack, using the FACE
(Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances) Act of 1994.
Some brave doctors
are declaring themselves as guilty of breaking these state laws, in
order to get a trial and force the US Supreme Court to declare
whether
Roe v Wade
is still the federal law or not
(and thus supersede state laws). However this is now something of a risky move, because
the US supreme court make-up is leaning more towards the conservative
right, after Donald Trumps last court appointment, with it now comprising of six socially conservative
justices, as opposed to three socially liberal .... so there is a
possibility that they will overthrow Roe v Wade ... in fact the liberal
establishment have been so rattled by this possibility, that President Joe
Biden has been forced to criticise the Texas Act, describing it as
"extreme" and saying it
"blatantly violates the constitutional right established under Roe v. Wade".
The fact that the USA is having this battle, and could even end up with women's rights reversing in many states, is actually worrying for women worldwide, because it would be used as a justification for far more regression by states and countries elsewhere.
According to a leaked document, the constitutional right to abortion in the US, guaranteed by 'Roe v Wade' (an absolute right to an abortion in the first three months of pregnancy, and limited rights in the second trimester) is to be completely overturned. in a shock move by the conservative dominated US Supreme Court. If true, then trigger clauses in 22 states will cause the right to an abortion to be instantly banned.
ReplyDeleteWomen's rights to their own bodies reproductive systems in very early pregnancy will effectively be removed in a large number of US states .... one can't help think that the USA it appears to be fracturing as a society, split forever between the Right and Left ... with almost two different countries emerging. This doesn't bode well for the future, especially if 'The Donald' runs again in two years time (as looks likely)
Why don't they simply hold a national referendum on whether abortion should be allowed? Surely that would settle the question with at least a reflection of the national will?
DeleteAs for splits on Left and Right. The USA is split on race as well.
On an earlier era the country would be ripe for breakups.
I'm not sure that a national vote would ease the tensions ... but an attempt to enshrine abortion rights at national/federal level was stymied by a Democrat voting against it.
DeleteThe USA (as well as other western countries) are increasingly riven by minorities demanding different rules for them (from policing, laws such as Sharia, to special religious protection) ... its a subject that will cause trouble in the future.
Thanks for the comment.
As if to prove the point .... Payton Gendron, an 18-year-old white man has shot dead 10 people in a black majority neighbourhood of New York state, in what the authorities are calling a racially motivated attack.
DeleteHe threatened a school graduation with a shooting in June 2021, and was given psychiatric treatment. He wore a hazmat suit to school for the first week of his senior year to protect against Covid restrictions - but still legally bought three guns. His parents are both engineers for the New York Department of Transportation.