And now a row has broken out after a research team, led by Professor Rob Lee from Exeter University in the UK, examined symbols on more than 200 carved stones, and concluded that the Pictish carvings were "symbolic markings that communicated information" - that these were words rather than pictures.
But French linguist Arnaud Fournet opened up the mystery once again by suggesting that this was not true and that the methods used to reach this conclusion were flawed.
Mr Fournet said that, by examining Pictish carvings as if they were "linear symbols", and by applying the rules of written language to them, the scientists could have produced biased results.
Mr Fournet also suggested that the researchers' methods should be tested and verified for other ancient symbols.
Personally I find it hard to believe that they were using pictographs when surrounded by writing from the surrounding kingdoms, even if it was just a few monks and clerics at local royal courts.
No one lives in isolation from the trends and ideas of their neighbours, and the Picts came from tribes that must have been exposed to Latin for centuries.
To me these are stories in pictures, but not words ..... they tell of events, but possibly just as prompts for well known stories ..... if you look in medieval churches, they often had pictures and stories from the Bible painted on the walls as prompts for the illiterate peasants, but the words were still wriiten in Latin in the Bibles.
These ancient standing stones with their stunning Pictish carvings are indeed pictures, they are in effect the ancient equivilant of "Roman's Go Home". A slogan that was apparently stolen and cruelly subjected to ridicule and laughter by the Monty Python team in the 80's.
ReplyDeleteI suggest that these people would be better replaced with a working Tram system and a Festivakl of the Arts in August.
The Romans had long gone mate ....well nearly LOL
ReplyDelete"and a Festival of the Arts in August." ... oops you got that one cos I am there from 19th August ... see ya for a 'gottle of geer' (see, my ventriloquist act is coming on a treat!)
There could be a "Rosetta Stone" for this language lying in a wall or field somewhere right now, unrecognised for what it is.
ReplyDeleteProbably a translation into Latin, written by a cleric or scribe.